skip to main content skip to footer

Full Menu

Appetizers

Old Mill Cheese Plate

$9.99

Pepperoni, salami, havarti, gouda, muenster with fresh seasonal fruit and warm crusty bread.

Old Mill Dip

$9.99

Roasted red pepper, cheese, sausage dip served in a bread boule with tortilla chips

Pretzel Sticks

$7.99

Baked and lightly salted large sticks, with dipping cheese sauce.

Zucchini Fries

$3.99

Shoestring-cut battered zucchini sticks.

New! Bread & Dipping Oil

$3.99

Loaf of toasted bread and a side of homemade dipping oil with italian spices.

Cheesy Garlic Bread

$6.99

Blended melted cheese and garlic served with marinara sauce

Chicken Tenderloin Strips

$7.99

Breaded chicken strips with your choice of sauce: honey mustard, ranch or BBQ

New! Loaded Potato Skins

$7.99

Baked skins, topped with nacho cheese and crumbled bacon, with a side of sour cream.

Crab Cakes

$8.99

Two handmade cakes with a perfect mix of crab and shrimp zesty roasted vegetables and spices, topped with spicy bistro sauce.

Steamed Mussels

$10.99

One pound of mussels in a garlic butter sauce, served with garlic bread.

Salads

Half orders of Salads $4.99

Add a Loaf of Bread & Honey Butter $1.99

Tropical Salad

$8.99

A taste of paradise...pineapple, dried cranberries, mandarin oranges, sugared pecans all atop our seasonal greens.

Bacon Blue

$9.99

Fresh seasonal green with crumbled blue cheese, bacon, tomato and red onion.

Add To Any Salad

Grilled Shrimp Skewer - $4.99
6 oz. Marinated Chicken Breast - $4.99
USDA Choice 6 oz. Sirloin Strip - $5.99

House Salad

$7.99

Entree size salad of seasonal greens with cheese, tomato, red onion, cucumber and croutons.

Cali Salad

$9.99

Fresh avocado, cheddar cheese,
crumbled bacon, tomato, croutons.

Wraps

Mexican Chicken

$8.99

Seasoned chicken, nacho cheese sauce, roasted corn, peppers and avocado.

Buffalo Chicken

$8.99

Spicy Buffalo breaded chicken, mixed lettuce, tomato and crumbled bleu cheese.

BLT

$7.99

Crispy bacon, mixed lettuce and fresh tomato with our house made chipotle mayo.

Beer-Battered Fish

$9.99

Baked filet, topped with creamy coleslaw, tomato and chipotle mayo drizzle.

Pulled Pork

$9.99

Seasoned pulled pork, with sweet BBQ sauce and creamy coleslaw.

Pizza

New Combinations!
On flatbread or round crust, also NEW cauliflower crust additional $3.50 
Look for our Pizza of the Month!

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$9.99

Old Mill Pizza

$9.99

garlic sauce, chopped chicken & a blend of melted cheese.

BBQ Pork & Onion

$9.99

Entrees

All entrees are served with vegetable and grilled redskin potato wedges. Substitute a baked potato or coleslaw. Add a side salad or loaf of bread and honey butter 1.99 each

Old Mill Strip Steak

$16.99

USDA Choice strip grilled to melt in your mouth perfection
Add grilled onions or mushrooms 1.29 each

Grilled Chicken

$14.99

Two juicy 6 oz chicken breasts in our secret wine BBQ sauce or choose a straight marinade

Surf & Turf

$25.99

Our famous strip steak with two shrimp skewers
Add grilled onions or mushrooms 1.29 Each

Crab Cakes

$13.99

Two handmade crab and shrimp filled cakes baked and served with spicy bistro sauce

Petite Sirloin

$14.99

USDA choice 6 oz sirloin for the lighter appetite. Grilled to order

Grilled Shrimp

$15.99

Two shrimp skewers hot off the grill with your choice of garlic, BBQ, cajun, or jerk

Baked Filet of Tilapia

$13.99

Parmesan herb shredded parmesan, italian herbs and savory panko

St. Louis Style Ribs

Our house favorite! Tender and meaty ribs, smothered in our secret wine BBQ sauce
Hlaf Rack 14.99 | Full Rack 19.99

You Pick Two

New!
You Pick Two For $17.99
Includes grilled redskins, seasonal vegetable.
*Must pick 2 different entrees to be eligible for this *2 for* special!

1/3 Rack Of Ribs

Grilled Chicken Breast

Crab Cake

Shrimp Skewer

6 oz. Petite Sirloin

Sandwiches

All sandwiches include lettuce, red onion and choice of American, Swiss, pepperjack or mozzarella cheese; served with pickle and chips. NEW Gluten Free bun $1.99
Add A Side Salad - $1.99
Add Waffle Fries - $3.99

Old Mill's Original Wine Burger

$10.99

Half pound Angus burger with wine marinade on a brioche bun, grilled to order!

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$8.99

Marinated chicken breast on a brioche bun.

Loaded Steak Sandwich

$12.99

Tender flattened filet, topped with mozzarella cheese, grilled onions & mushrooms

Beer Battered Fish Hoagie

$9.99

Baked cod, topped with cheese and creamy coleslaw

Veggie Burger

$8.99

New! Vegan Beyond Burger.

Loaded WineBurger

$13.99

Our famous wineburger topped with grilled onions, mushrooms & bacon

Pulled Pork Sandwich

$9.99

Smothered BBQ pulled pork topped with creamy coleslaw

Pasta

All pastas include, garlic bread.

Add a side salad or loaf of bread & honey butter $1.99

Spaghetti & Meatballs

$8.29

A generous portion featuring our wine infused marinara sauce with two meatballs.
Add Extra Meatball - $0.99 each

Mushroom Raviolis

$10.99

Portabella-stuffed raviolis, covered in our wine-infused Alfredo sauce.

Garlic Chicken Pasta

$12.99

Spaghetti topped with a garlic cream sauce, with crispy chicken covered in cheese

Niagara Pasta Alfredo

$9.99

Our house alfredo sauce with a hint of our own white Niagara over a hearty portion of pasta.

Customize Your Alfredo Add

Grilled Shrimp Skewer - $4.99
6 oz. Marinated Chicken Breast - $4.99
USDA Choice 6 oz. Sirloin Strip - $5.99

Beverages

Coffee

Regular and Decaf, 3 Free Refills!

Soft Drinks

3 Free Refills!

Hot Tea & Iced Tea

3 Free Refills!

Bottled Water

Milk

White or Chocolate

Grape Juice

Hot Cocoa

Coke SLUSHIE

$2.99

Dessert

Ask Your Server For The Dessert Selection Of The Day!

Wine

White

Chardonnay

A very complex white wine with a hint of oak. Perfect for fish or white meat.
Grape: Chardonnay $6.00 Glass | $17.99 Bottle

Grindstone White

A delightfully sweet dessert wine similar in style to the French Sauternes, but made from the most popular native Niagara grape.
Grape: Niagara $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Geneva Blanc

A very fruity, semi-sweet and fun wine, perfect for social drinking.
Grape: Niagara $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Riesling

German style. Slightly sweet, lots of flavor.
Grape: Riesling $6.00 Glass | $16.99 Bottle

Cayuga

A dry white wine with a crisp, light taste.
Grape: Cayuga $6.00 Glass | $16.99 Bottle

Red

Geneva Rouge

Semi-sweet and fruity, full of bold Concord grape flavors. Perfect for Sangria Coolers or mulled wine.
Grape: Concord $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Grindstone Red

Sweet, dark red and fruity. Very similar in style to the Italian Lambrusco.
Grape: Concord $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Fredonia

Semi Dry Red wine, fruity fun wine, closest to a merlot

Grape: Fredonia $6.00 Glass | $17.99 Bottle

Chambourcin

A dry red wine with a hint of cherry.
Grape: Chambourcin $6.00 Glass | $17.99 Bottle

Cabernet Franc

Dry Red Wine full body

Grape: Cab Franc $6.00 Glass | $17.99 Bottle

Blush

Geneva Blush

A light, fruity pink wine, similar to the White Zinfandel.
Grape: Catawba $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Grindstone Pink

A sweet wine with a fine, fruity flavor. An excellent wine for Sangria Coolers.
Grape: Catawba $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Fruit

Geneva Summer Berry

Sweet wine, made with grape, blueberry, red raspberry & black berry wine.
Bottle $15.99 | Glass $6.00        SLUSHIE $7.50

Beer

Domestic Bottled Beer

Bud Light

Miller Lite

O'Doul's

Non-Alcoholic

Michelob Ultra

Coors Light

Yuengling

Budweiser

Imports & Specialty Beers

Great Lakes Seasonal

Rotating Beer Selection, NEW NEW NEW

Great Lakes Dortmunder Gold

Sangria Coolers

Bottle Price Plus

$2.99

Glass Price Plus

$1.59

Tastings

$0.50

Each

Gluten Free Menu

Our Entrees are Gluten Free, just tell the server no garlic bread

Gluten Free Items

White Chicken Pizza

$8.99

With a garlic sauce, chicken, and a blend of mozzarella & parmesan cheeses.

Veggie Red Pizza

With Marinara sauce, mushrooms, grilled onions, peppers, and chopped tomatoes, with and a blend of mozzarella & parmesan cheeses.

Old Mill Dip & Chips

$8.99

Penne Pasta

With Marinara, sprinkled with parmesan cheese.
Add - Grilled Chicken $2.99 | Grilled Steak $3.99 | Shrimp Skewer $3.99

Penne Alfredo Pasta

With a Creamy Alfredo
sprinkled with Parmesan cheese.
Add - Grilled Chicken $2.99 | Grilled Steak $3.99 | Shrimp Skewer $3.99

Gueten Free Bun

$1.99

get for  any sandwich!

Kids

Kids

Cheese burger

$5.99

Amreica cheese, served with chips & grapes

French Bread Pizza

$4.99

Served with chips & grapes

Noodles & Meatball

$2.99

With marinara sauce & cheese

Salad

$1.99

Mixed lettuce, cheese, tomato, cucumber & croutons

Chicken Tenders

$4.99

Served with chips & grapes

Noodles

$2.99

Buttered noodles, with cheese

Corn Dog

$3.99

Served with chips & grapes

Drinks

$1.99

Grape Juice | Chocolate Milk | White Milk | Sprite | Rootbeer | Lemonade

Small with lid