skip to main content skip to footer

Full Menu

Appetizers

Old Mill Cheese Plate

$9.99

Pepperoni, salami, havarti, gouda, muenster with fresh seasonal fruit and warm crusty bread.

Old Mill Dip

$9.99

Roasted red pepper, cheese, sausage dip served in a bread boule with tortilla chips

Pretzel Sticks

$7.99

Baked and lightly salted large sticks, with dipping cheese sauce.

Zucchini Fries

$3.99

Shoestring-cut battered zucchini sticks.

New! Bread & Dipping Oil

$3.99

Loaf of toasted bread and a side of homemade dipping oil with italian spices.

Cheesy Garlic Bread

$6.99

Blended melted cheese and garlic served with marinara sauce

Chicken Tenderloin Strips

$7.99

Breaded chicken strips with your choice of sauce: honey mustard, ranch or BBQ

New! Loaded Potato Skins

$7.99

Baked skins, topped with nacho cheese and crumbled bacon, with a side of sour cream.

Crab Cakes

$8.99

Two handmade cakes with a perfect mix of crab and shrimp zesty roasted vegetables and spices, topped with spicy bistro sauce.

Steamed Mussels

$10.99

One pound of mussels in a garlic butter sauce, served with garlic bread.

Salads

Half orders of Salads $4.99

Add a Loaf of Bread & Honey Butter $1.99

Tropical Salad

$8.99

A taste of paradise...pineapple, dried cranberries, mandarin oranges, sugared pecans all atop our seasonal greens.

Bacon Blue

$9.99

Fresh seasonal green with crumbled blue cheese, bacon, tomato and red onion.

Add To Any Salad

Grilled Shrimp Skewer - $4.99
6 oz. Marinated Chicken Breast - $4.99
USDA Choice 6 oz. Sirloin Strip - $5.99

House Salad

$7.99

Entree size salad of seasonal greens with cheese, tomato, red onion, cucumber and croutons.

Cali Salad

$9.99

Fresh avocado, cheddar cheese,
crumbled bacon, tomato, croutons.

Wraps

Mexican Chicken

$8.99

Seasoned chicken, nacho cheese sauce, roasted corn, peppers and avocado.

Buffalo Chicken

$8.99

Spicy Buffalo breaded chicken, mixed lettuce, tomato and crumbled bleu cheese.

BLT

$7.99

Crispy bacon, mixed lettuce and fresh tomato with our house made chipotle mayo.

Beer-Battered Fish

$9.99

Baked filet, topped with creamy coleslaw, tomato and chipotle mayo drizzle.

Pulled Pork

$9.99

Seasoned pulled pork, with sweet BBQ sauce and creamy coleslaw.

Pizza

New Combinations!
On flatbread or round crust, also NEW cauliflower crust additional $3.50 
Look for our Pizza of the Month!

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$9.99

BBQ Pork & Onion

$9.99

Pesto

$9.99

homemade pesto sauce, chopped tomatoes & cheese, with a balsamic drizzel. Add chicken .99

Old Mill Pizza

$9.99

garlic sauce, chopped chicken & a blend of melted cheese.

Entrees

All entrees are served with vegetable and grilled redskin potato wedges. Substitute a baked potato or coleslaw. Add a side salad or loaf of bread and honey butter 1.99 each

Old Mill Strip Steak

$16.99

USDA Choice strip grilled to melt in your mouth perfection
Add grilled onions or mushrooms 1.29 each

Grilled Chicken

$14.99

Two juicy 6 oz chicken breasts in our secret wine BBQ sauce or choose a straight marinade

Surf & Turf

$25.99

Our famous strip steak with two shrimp skewers
Add grilled onions or mushrooms 1.29 Each

Crab Cakes

$13.99

Two handmade crab and shrimp filled cakes baked and served with spicy bistro sauce

Petite Sirloin

$14.99

USDA choice 6 oz sirloin for the lighter appetite. Grilled to order

Grilled Shrimp

$15.99

Two shrimp skewers hot off the grill with your choice of garlic, BBQ, cajun, or jerk

Baked Filet of Tilapia

$13.99

Your choice of coconut-crusted tilapia with dried mango and island seasoning or parmesan herb shredded parmesan, italian herbs and savory panko

St. Louis Style Ribs

Our house favorite! Tender and meaty ribs, smothered in our secret wine BBQ sauce
Hlaf Rack 14.99 | Full Rack 19.99

You Pick Two

New!
You Pick Two For $17.99
Includes grilled redskins, seasonal vegetable.
*Must pick 2 different entrees to be eligible for this *2 for* special!

1/3 Rack Of Ribs

Grilled Chicken Breast

Crab Cake

Shrimp Skewer

6 oz. Petite Sirloin

Sandwiches

All sandwiches include lettuce, red onion and choice of American, Swiss, pepperjack or mozzarella cheese; served with pickle and chips. NEW Gluten Free bun $1.99
Add A Side Salad - $1.99
Add Waffle Fries - $3.99

Old Mill's Original Wine Burger

$10.99

Half pound Angus burger with wine marinade on a brioche bun, grilled to order!

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$8.99

Marinated chicken breast on a brioche bun.

Loaded Steak Sandwich

$12.99

Tender flattened filet, topped with mozzarella cheese, grilled onions & mushrooms

Beer Battered Fish Hoagie

$9.99

Baked cod, topped with cheese and creamy coleslaw

Veggie Burger

$8.99

New! Vegan Beyond Burger.

Loaded WineBurger

$13.99

Our famous wineburger topped with grilled onions, mushrooms & bacon

Pulled Pork Sandwich

$9.99

Smothered BBQ pulled pork topped with creamy coleslaw

Pasta

All pastas include, garlic bread.

Add a side salad or loaf of bread & honey butter $1.99

Spaghetti & Meatballs

$8.29

A generous portion featuring our wine infused marinara sauce with two meatballs.
Add Extra Meatball - $0.99 each

Mushroom Raviolis

$10.99

Portabella-stuffed raviolis, covered in our wine-infused Alfredo sauce.

Garlic Chicken Pasta

$12.99

Spaghetti topped with a garlic cream sauce, with crispy chicken covered in cheese

Niagara Pasta Alfredo

$9.99

Our house alfredo sauce with a hint of our own white Niagara over a hearty portion of pasta.

Customize Your Alfredo Add

Grilled Shrimp Skewer - $4.99
6 oz. Marinated Chicken Breast - $4.99
USDA Choice 6 oz. Sirloin Strip - $5.99

Beverages

Coffee

Regular and Decaf, 3 Free Refills!

Soft Drinks

3 Free Refills!

Hot Tea & Iced Tea

3 Free Refills!

Bottled Water

Milk

White or Chocolate

Grape Juice

Hot Cocoa

Coke SLUSHIE

$2.99

Dessert

Ask Your Server For The Dessert Selection Of The Day!

Wine

White

Chardonnay

A very complex white wine with a hint of oak. Perfect for fish or white meat.
Grape: Chardonnay $6.00 Glass | $17.99 Bottle

Grindstone White

A delightfully sweet dessert wine similar in style to the French Sauternes, but made from the most popular native Niagara grape.
Grape: Niagara $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Geneva Blanc

A very fruity, semi-sweet and fun wine, perfect for social drinking.
Grape: Niagara $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Riesling

German style. Slightly sweet, lots of flavor.
Grape: Riesling $6.00 Glass | $16.99 Bottle

Cayuga

A dry white wine with a crisp, light taste.
Grape: Cayuga $6.00 Glass | $16.99 Bottle

Red

Geneva Rouge

Semi-sweet and fruity, full of bold Concord grape flavors. Perfect for Sangria Coolers or mulled wine.
Grape: Concord $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Grindstone Red

Sweet, dark red and fruity. Very similar in style to the Italian Lambrusco.
Grape: Concord $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Chambourcin

A dry red wine with a hint of cherry.
Grape: Chambourcin $6.00 Glass | $17.99 Bottle

Blush

Geneva Blush

A light, fruity pink wine, similar to the White Zinfandel.
Grape: Catawba $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Grindstone Pink

A sweet wine with a fine, fruity flavor. An excellent wine for Sangria Coolers.
Grape: Catawba $5.00 Glass | $14.99 Bottle

Fruit

Geneva Summer Berry

Sweet wine, made with grape, blueberry, red raspberry & black berry wine.
Bottle $15.99 | Glass $6.00        SLUSHIE $7.50

Beer

Domestic Bottled Beer

Bud Light

Miller Lite

O'Doul's

Non-Alcoholic

Michelob Ultra

Coors Light

Yuengling

Budweiser

Imports & Specialty Beers

Great Lakes Seasonal

Rotating Beer Selection, NEW NEW NEW

Great Lakes Dortmunder Gold

Sangria Coolers

Bottle Price Plus

$2.99

Glass Price Plus

$1.59

Tastings

$0.50

Each

Gluten Free Menu

Our Entrees are Gluten Free, just tell the server no garlic bread

Gluten Free Items

White Chicken Pizza

$8.99

With a garlic sauce, chicken, and a blend of mozzarella & parmesan cheeses.

Veggie Red Pizza

With Marinara sauce, mushrooms, grilled onions, peppers, and chopped tomatoes, with and a blend of mozzarella & parmesan cheeses.

Old Mill Dip & Chips

$8.99

Penne Pasta

With Marinara, sprinkled with parmesan cheese.
Add - Grilled Chicken $2.99 | Grilled Steak $3.99 | Shrimp Skewer $3.99

Penne Alfredo Pasta

With a Creamy Alfredo
sprinkled with Parmesan cheese.
Add - Grilled Chicken $2.99 | Grilled Steak $3.99 | Shrimp Skewer $3.99

Gueten Free Bun

$1.99

get for  any sandwich!

Kids

Kids

Cheese burger

$5.99

Amreica cheese, served with chips & grapes

French Bread Pizza

$4.99

Served with chips & grapes

Noodles & Meatball

$2.99

With marinara sauce & cheese

Salad

$1.99

Mixed lettuce, cheese, tomato, cucumber & croutons

Chicken Tenders

$4.99

Served with chips & grapes

Noodles

$2.99

Buttered noodles, with cheese

Corn Dog

$3.99

Served with chips & grapes

Drinks

$1.99

Grape Juice | Chocolate Milk | White Milk | Sprite | Rootbeer | Lemonade

Small with lid